CivWiki:Policies and guidelines

From CivWiki
(Redirected from CW:FRONTPAGE)
Jump to navigation Jump to search

CivWiki has various policies and guidelines which guide how to edit CivWiki.

In a nutshell, CivWiki defers to Wikipedia policies. There are some exceptions, since CivWiki is not Wikipedia.

Defer to Wikipedia

Wikipedia has been around for more than two decades and has encountered almost every possible combination of circumstances or editing conflicts, and has developed an extensive set of policies that make for a good encyclopedia (of which CivWiki is one). Replicating this collection of policies alone on CivWiki would be an enormous effort. When CivWiki has nothing new to add, we will not state a policy at all, and instead simply defer to the relevant Wikipedia policy.

This includes policies like Wikipedia's Manual of Style, naming conventions, and policy on consensus, to name a few.

In short: in the absence of a CivWiki policy to the contrary, assume that the relevant Wikipedia policy holds.

CivWiki is not Wikipedia

Although CivWiki defers to Wikipedia, CivWiki is not Wikipedia, and has different requirements and needs. While Wikipedia is a general encyclopedia, CivWiki documents a very narrow genre of Minecraft servers, and caters to a smaller base of readers. For instance, CivWiki can assume readers are familiar with certain mechanics of vanilla Minecraft, where Wikipedia cannot.

Sometimes, these different needs means that CivWiki policies will be different from, or contain exceptions to, Wikipedia policies. As one example, CivWiki's notability policy is significantly looser than Wikipedia's, which is a result of the smaller base of readers and increased interest in documenting one's own history among those readers.

Notability (nations)

While CivWiki is not Wikipedia, nations must still meet a bare minimum of coverage to be notable. A nation is notable if any of the following conditions are met:

  • The nation has (or had) a significant physical presence on the server, for a moderate amount of time. That is, not necessarily a bustling city, but more than a few simple houses and small farms.
  • The nation has (or had) a substantial influence on server-wide geopolitics for a moderate amount of time. This includes nations that were substantially involved in a conflict that was itself notable. (Compare similar notability exceptions carved out in WP:1E).
  • The nation would have been widely recognized by the average player of the server for a moderate amount of time. "Average" here means the average player who regularly logged in or regularly read the subreddit. It is not necessarily only players who spent large amounts of time logged in to the server, or only players who regularly engaged in discussions.

The final clause is intended to be a catchall exception that, while more difficult to apply, allows for nations that were widely known to players at the time (but perhaps without significant physical presence) to be notable under CivWiki.

Tabbed servers order

Plugin pages often use the Tabber extension to display information for multiple Civ servers, for example Citadel § Reinforcement Materials. In these cases, servers should be ordered from left to right as follows:

Conflict infoboxes

When using Template:Infobox military conflict to document conflicts, do not include the "Commanders and leaders" section. This section is too difficult to verify to be worth including[1].

A "combatant" is anyone who has taken damage from, or given damage to, someone from the opposing side, or has been meaningfully involved in the creation or transfer of logistic supplies, or building military infrastructure directly relevant to the conflict. In the conflict infobox, mark a combatant as pearled if they were pearled at any point during the conflict, even if they were later freed. [2]

Unless there is a compelling reason otherwise, use the following layout for the images in the infobox[3]:

  • Large image
  • Image gallery
  • Map

Conflict naming

The naming of a conflict page reflects subjective editor consensus, progressing through three stages.[4]

  1. When a conflict begins, the conflict should be named as generically as possible while being specific enough to remove any ambiguity. Typically, this involves including the place and/or time of the war. For example, a war between Estalia and Pavia would be called the Pavia–Estalian War, while a war involving many nations on CivMC in 2025 might be called the 2025 CivMC War.
  2. At some point after the conflict begins, one or more reasonably good candidates for a name is likely to emerge. CivWiki editors should determine via consensus which of these names to use. Editors may always decide to continue to use the existing article title.
  3. If afterwards a different common name emerges, the article should be renamed to the common name. This requires the strong form of "common name" described by wikipedia.

This is a notable departure from Wikipedia's common name guidelines. Because CivWiki can itself create naming consensus among players, CivWiki must be careful not to accidentally cause a neutral, boring, placeholder name to become the common name.

This three-stage progression balances the need for an article title with caution against renaming too early, while still respecting general community consensus. In the first stage, the article is given a neutral placeholder name. To avoid creating consensus around this name, the article is then given a new, better name in stage two, once reasonable candidates emerge.

Note that because stage two requires a weaker and more ambiguous standard than Wikipedia's common name, decisions here will necessarily be subjective, imprecise, and unlikely to satisfy everyone. Where necessary, CivWiki administrators will make the final call.

Front page servers

On the main page, a server can be listed under "live servers" if it can be actively joined, and either:

  • Released less than 21 days ago
  • Consistently has a minimum peak of at least 5 players daily

Notes