Talk:RainOfPain125

From CivWiki
Latest comment: 2 October by Goneguy in topic Un true
Jump to navigation Jump to search

Archive: Talk:RainOfPain125/Archive 1

Biased?

Which section of this edit do you believe is biased? @Tybug

https://civwiki.org/wiki/RainOfPain125?oldid=114327 RainOfPain125 (talk) 06:05, 1 September 2026 (UTC)Reply

you are a deeply unserious person if you cannot answer that question yourself, if you continue making edits like this you will be banned Tybug (talk) 06:34, 1 September 2026 (UTC)Reply
You've been making these decisions without explaining your rationale one bit, which is not very good wiki moderation. To me it just seems like you're looking for an excuse to ban Rain, as I asked you to explain why Rain was sanctioned in the first place and you didn't. Please point to exactly what was biased about the edit in question. MrJoCrafter (talk) 13:47, 1 September 2026 (UTC)Reply
I'm honestly with Tybug here, this is a very, very obviously biased article. In addition to the reasons I added a neutrality warning to the page, which are listed in the summary, this particular version of this page describes Zenron as naive, his ban as frivolous, specifically implicates players as spreading "wild rumors" (a phrase I don't imagine is ever appropriate for an article on this wiki to use), and straight up just lists a bunch of accusations against CivMC's admin team. This article often mixes third-person narration with clearly first-person accounts of events and opinions (why would it matter to a CivWiki article what certain events prove to Rain specifically? To who is the correspondence with Zenron "the most interesting thing?) which is blatantly misleading and presents subjective judgements around serious points of contention as objective, and goes against the mission of clarity and accuracy of information that this Wiki is made to contain.
I don't have an issue with content on this wiki that isn't strictly objective, and I'd rather an autobiographical player page than a red link- but obscuring how much of this article was written from Rain's perspective, and platforming certain accounts over others (without any sourcing or suitably general knowledge) in regards to topics that demand objectivity and care, is obviously not an appropriate way to write this kind of page, and allowing this wiki to host such hostile and colored rhetoric against named players and regarding specific instances of doxxing feels to me an actively dangerous precedent to set Oceanstar (talk) 23:52, 3 September 2026 (UTC)Reply
while i do agree with this sentiment and i do not agree with like anything that rain writes, it's also his own page? players are given essentially free liberty over their own user pages and i think that's a good thing, if the neutrality warning is put at the top to clearly indicate that the article is #very #biased then what justification would there be to regulate it any further? as long as it doesn't have like PII or anything in that vein
i may be wrong just asking Presidentofyes12 (talk) 02:42, 4 September 2026 (UTC)Reply
I agree with that in general- player perspectives are absolutely useful information to have- but the language this article feels deceptive to me. It's not indicated anywhere that the content here is individual opinion, and it's not easy to discern the providence of any particular claims here or how few or how many people are represented by them. And when that becomes specific accusations of malice or incompetence in reference to named players and admins, without sourcing, that becomes misinformation with a capacity for actual and direct harm. In that kind of situation, there's some obligation to be more neutral, more objective, and describe events as they are widely understood to have actually happened, with citations, multiple if possible, to support how we're describing them
I'd be open to some wider discussion on that- obviously it's difficult to talk about active controversies from an individual perspective while remaining objective, since there isn't a consensus for the wiki to present, and minority positions can still be legitimate ones. But I don't think we've seen enough evidence in this specific article to justify how hostile it is, nor is the way the article formatted clearly articulating that it is presenting an individual perspective at all.
Really, I think there's actually a huge difference in how player articles written by that player, to share their perspective on events they witnessed, function, when compared to more encyclopedic articles written about that player and the interactions they had with the world; and we need the distinction between the two to be more easily recognizable Oceanstar (talk) 12:44, 4 September 2026 (UTC)Reply
the language this article feels deceptive to me. It's not indicated anywhere that the content here is individual opinion
"Rain found this behavior from the staff team to be incredibly unprofessional and disrespectful, making someone wait 3 weeks only to have absolutely no discussion."
"The most interesting part [to Rain], however, was the exchange that zairaaaa had with Rain after the ticket was abruptly closed."
"The CivMC staff team working to knowingly withhold information that may otherwise prove his innocence, proves to Rain that the CivMC staff team are bad actors engaging in deliberately malicious, harmful, unfair activity."
without sourcing, that becomes misinformation with a capacity for actual and direct harm.
The edit was reverted for "biased", not "lack of citations". I was going to add my citations in the next edit. Publishing the facts of the matter before going on vacation seemed important, especially due to the circumstances at the time.
In that kind of situation, there's some obligation to be more neutral, more objective, and describe events as they are widely understood to have actually happened
A ban and ban appeal are not things to be "described as widely understood to have happened" because they are one-on-one conversations between the admin team and the banned player. Nobody has information or an understanding of the "events as they are widely understood to have actually happened" except me at the admin team. I highly welcome the admin team to come publicly clarify their ban, and their evidence to support their ban. But they have had years to do so, and have failed for years. Until then, I am the only source on this matter. If someone else outside of the admin team had sources on this matter, that would be concerning.
obviously it's difficult to talk about active controversies
This ban occurred 4 years ago. The first ban appeal occurred 4 years ago. The second ban appeal occurred 5 months ago. This is not an "active controversy". RainOfPain125 (talk) 01:02, 5 September 2026 (UTC)Reply
@Oceanstar @Lodish Hello, I'd still like to have this matter addressed.
I propose, instead of vaguely arguing back and fourth and being stuck at an impasse, one of you could lend help in writing an "unbiased" edit of the facts of the matter (that still includes my opinion, since it is relevant) that were written in the edit we've been discussing.
Because the issue is it seems very much so that Tybug has no intention of ever directly addressing what may have made it biased, or the concerns that other users (like @MrJoCrafter) have raised regarding seemingly unfair moderation.
And from Tybug's own vague words, "if you continue making edits like this you will be banned". Which given the context and established history of unexplained punishments, seems like a very strongly worded threat to nuke my account if I dare re-introduce the facts of the matter, no matter how I may reword it. Because of how incredibly vague Tybug has been, and the lack of elaboration or follow-up, I will in fact elect not to dare!
This is why I am asking if one of you can provide a rewritten sample that we can all agree to be "unbiased".
Maybe after we can discuss removing the neutrality warning from the page, since no examples of biased language were cited, and the page has since then been a bit rehashed by @Lodish to improve neutrality.
Thanks. RainOfPain125 (talk) 02:52, 13 September 2026 (UTC)Reply
Apologies, I have a hard time reading big talk pages, I find the formatting hard to comprehend, and also just in general I am quite lazy. I've occasionally tried to improve the page but I think there's more improvements to be made, generally lots of small language things, words and phrases like: "obliterated", "championed", "empower", "descending into fascism" when used outside of a direct quote imply things a citation could never back up. Then there's also just a lot of narrative storytelling which isn't the worst sin but doesn't really work in an Encyclopedia, like "Rain saw CivUniverse as an opportunity to begin again" makes perfect sense and I'm sure is true but the actual facts to be reported would be the much more boring "Rain joined CivUniverse in 2020".
I do appreciate the work you @RainOfPain125 have put into other CivWiki pages, and I can understand wanting to tell your story. I wonder if maybe you'd have a better time expressing what happened in a formal interview where you could be opinionated as you like and tell a full narrative from which you could be quoted from and the publication of that interview would be a citation for details that you would only know. I don't think it's quite at the NPOV removal point yet, there's more I plan to do if others don't and would like to soon get the article to the point that the warnings can be removed. I have also tried to contact other people involved in events but so far no one has replied to my efforts. Somewhere in this talk page you mention "I was going to add my citations in the next edit" have those citations now been added? I feel like more sources would help me check other perspective's on events, for instance I have no idea where I'd go to find election results or election campaigns mentioned or to see what 'Wobblies' or 'crab coup' people or Acadians or Wyvern people were saying at the actual time. Lodish (talk) 01:11, 17 September 2026 (UTC)Reply
Apologies
its all good.
Somewhere in this talk page you mention "I was going to add my citations in the next edit" have those citations now been added?
This was in reference to providing citations / evidence specifically regarding the content Tybug deleted. Since the content is no longer on the page, there is no longer a need for the content's citations. Cart before the horse.
I feel like more sources would help me check other perspective's on events, for instance I have no idea where I'd go to find election results or election campaigns mentioned or to see what 'Wobblies' or 'crab coup' people or Acadians or Wyvern people were saying at the actual time.
I mean, I agree. Its difficult to find such sources of evidence or opinions for old events. Regarding wobblies/IWW vote I can probably pull up a copy of the election document. Since I gave away ownership of the IWW Discord I have no ability to review old chats, and the account that currently owns the server seems to be completely inactive.
Regarding Wyvern, not much to be said. I was only there briefly and all the comms were done on my old depreciated Discord account. Without checking the Wyvern wiki page I couldn't name a single player that was in Wyvern. Even reviewing the page, I don't remember any of the names I interacted with. RainOfPain125 (talk) 07:11, 17 September 2026 (UTC)Reply
It is absolutely reasonably for people who haven't actually broken the rules (which Rain hasn't, at least according to anything I'm aware of) have not been giving a ban reason (which Rain definitely, verifiably hasn't) to describe their bans as frivolous. If the admins refuse to give a reason, assuming it's for no reason is Occam's Razor. See: my case as well. MrJoCrafter (talk) 00:31, 5 September 2026 (UTC)Reply
Also, @Oceanstar, you say Rain accuses the admins of banning him frivolously "without a source", but what source could be provided to defend oneself from a charge which they refuse to specify? If Rain was banned for some specific reason, he could refute that with a source. But the admins *refuse* to give him a reason. To this day. You're asking him to cite to something that doesn't exist. MrJoCrafter (talk) 00:36, 5 September 2026 (UTC)Reply
Do you have a screenshot of an empty ticket? A DM left on read? Anything to justify the claims that are made? And there's many, many more instances of unsourced claims in this article than just that specific example. I'd also like any evidence that withholding ban information is nonstandard somehow, because to my knowledge, that's been the typical way of handling bans since Classics, and CivMC's team has continued that practice. And of course, that's to say nothing of the choice of such emotionally charged language in an article here. You say it's reasonable for Rain to describe his experiences that way, but that's a different argument- this article is not framed to make it clear that this is Rain's account of events, and that's one of my main problems with it Oceanstar (talk) 00:52, 5 September 2026 (UTC)Reply
Withholding ban *information* (i.e. confidentially provided evidence) is a common practice yes, but back during Classics the admin team would actually tell people why they got banned. Withholding ban *reasons* from the general public is one thing, but from the individual who is banned? That's a moderation policy which can only be accurately be described as arbitrary and capricious. MrJoCrafter (talk) 00:58, 5 September 2026 (UTC)Reply
I agree fully with MrJoCrafter. Admins should be held to a high standard, and the precedent set by the Civ genre as far back as CivClassics is for admins to disclose to the banned player(s) the reason behind their ban. CivMC has gone above and beyond to obscure the facts and withhold information, refusing to tell select banned players why they are banned at all.
CivClassics even had the decency to publicly clarify why I was only banned for 1 month for "doxing" after I specifically requested them to do so. They respected and understood that players were running wild generating rumors, trying to slander the situation as far worse than it was. The CivClassics admin team set the record straight on my behalf, saving me a lot of reputation and issues with slander, rumors, etc.
https://www.reddit.com/r/civclassics/comments/pv6iji/rainie_ban_details/ RainOfPain125 (talk) 01:09, 5 September 2026 (UTC)Reply
You all might have an argument that CivMC's policy departs from the standard set by CivClassics, but that does *not* support the argument that the current CivMC admins are specifically departing from their usual policy in regards to your case. What standard the admins *should* be held to, what policies are arbitrary and capricious, and what justice means in the context of administration is a subjective judgement that cannot simply be assumed, is not included in the article in question, and frankly, is well beyond the article's scope. Oceanstar (talk) 01:37, 5 September 2026 (UTC)Reply
Do you have a screenshot of an empty ticket?
for the 2nd/latest ban appeal? yes.
refer to attached images[1][2] RainOfPain125 (talk) 01:18, 5 September 2026 (UTC)Reply
I'm not asking for you to give them to me, I'm asking you to *source your claims*. I do not understand why this wasn't included if you have this stuff so readily Oceanstar (talk) 01:33, 5 September 2026 (UTC)Reply
describes Zenron as naive
Given the facts of the case, it was naïve of Zenron to suggest I file a ban appeal. Just as it would be naïve for anyone else to do the same.
  1. I already filed a ban appeal previously. This is public knowledge.
  2. The original ban appeal was denied despite me breaking no rules, and no evidence against me provided. This is public knowledge.
I am not saying Zenron as a person is naïve, I am saying their suggestion for me to file a ban appeal was. They cannot help that, and thats fine. But clarifying the obvious is not problematic nor "biased".
[describes] his ban as frivolous
If I banned someone with no reason provided, with no evidence to support my ban, then denied their ban appeal, it would be a frivolous ban. Frivolous: "Inappropriately silly". The ban is both silly and inappropriate. This terminology is correct and not "biased".
specifically implicates players as spreading "wild rumors"
Do you want citation examples of CivMC players spreading rumors in their vein attempts to guess the true nature of my ban? Because they are plentiful. And one can imagine without examples given, that the community would speculate over unfounded bans, no? That is human nature. People gossip. We are all people.
You can argue the exact wording or verbiage is hyperbole. Choice language such as "running wild" is to emphasize a point. But emphasizing a point is not "bias".
why would it matter to a CivWiki article what certain events prove to Rain specifically?
Understanding, demonstrating, or expressing someone's beliefs, ideas, or convictions is perfectly in line for a page about a specific person. And explaining a person's beliefs is not "biased", even if their belief may be biased. What would be wrong, is if the person's beliefs were presented as a statement of fact instead of personal opinion. And I specifically wrote in such a way as to make it clear that it was an opinion.
To who is the correspondence with Zenron "the most interesting thing?
Obviously the entire situation is interesting: Being banned despite following the rules, given no reason for the ban, given no evidence to support the ban, having both ban appeals denied is already interesting. What is exceptionally interesting (I think most people would agree, no?) is an official admin admitting that they want to share the reason for the ban, but were forbidden from doing so.
Can you name any particular part about the situation that is arguably any more interesting and deserves the title of most interesting?
allowing this wiki to host such hostile and colored rhetoric against named players
I do not see what is "hostile" about explaining the situation and details behind my ban and ban appeals. I have never said Zenron is a "bad person" (someone claims I called them a bad person, but I never have nor never implied this). Nor do I see how it is "biased" to explain the details or the ban and the ban appeals.
I asked tybug to elaborate on why he believed it was "biased" and he has failed to do so. Instead he made backhanded fun of my intelligence and threatened to ban my account. If he had reverted my edit with the reason "lack of citations" (as opposed to "biased") and didn't threaten to ban me if I tried to fix the issues, then I'd feel comfortable/safe to restore the content with the appropriate citations. But instead, tybug has explicitly chosen to threaten and coerce his way into making sure the facts of the matter are not presented. RainOfPain125 (talk) 00:48, 5 September 2026 (UTC)Reply
Okay, stating that you believe "naive", "frivolous", or "wild rumors" to be appropriate descriptors does not make them any less subjective judgements. It is not "correct terminology"; there is no official policy denoting appropriate use cases for such words on this wiki, nor is there any sort of objective standard for judging exactly how the conduct in question qualifies. Also, "public knowledge" and "the obvious" are not citable sources. You cannot just wave your hands towards the concept of people knowing what happened on a wiki article. What "one can imagine" is also not tangible evidence. And yeah, if they're plentiful, cite them! Are you arguing that the existence of sources makes them unnecessary to include?
No, this article is not written in any specific way that clarifies the subjectivity of it's authorship. A third-person narrative voice describing events implies some degree of objectivity in perspective; limited omniscience in relation to a focus character is a standard way to write a book, but it'd be very odd to write an autobiography; it's a first-person narrative written using third-person language with no explicit clarification, which is not a standard way to write an encyclopedia.
In no part of your response have you actually detailed your reason for making a judgement about what part of this story is "the most interesting" at all. My argument isn't that that is an unreasonable thing to believe, it is that belief is not the determiner of legitimacy in inclusion in an article that does not adequately communicate its own perspective in plain English. My opinion on the specific instance doesn't matter any more than yours; that it is an opinion at all is the issue.
I don't believe for a second that you can't see how this article is hostile to your opponents. In a page that consistently frames your experience as one of outright persecution, you describe opponents "completely failing", accuse them of unprofessionalism, use quotations in unnecessary locations to delegitimize charges against you, "opting for harassment", and continuously make claims as to the legitimacy of all of your controversies without sourcing definitive resolutions for them. Outside of instances of explicitly hostile wording, the voice used in much of this article also serves to delegitimize counterarguments without engaging with them directly.
I'm not even going to argue whether the use of hostile language in all of these cases is *correct*- I think in at least some of this there is ample justification for the descriptions used- but those justifications aren't cited, and you deny using hostile rhetoric at all, when that is just clearly not true.
I don't know how you explicitly say in one paragraph that this article is a description of events from your perspective while also claiming it to be unbiased. That is just definitionally mutually exclusive. Whether your bias is legitimately representative of the actual events, or not, is not under argument right now- that's subject to an entirely different discussion. There is no specific substance of this article that *is* biased, because that's not what bias means. Bias is an implicit argument communicated through the article as a whole, and it is an inherent part of every individual author. If you aren't contesting how this article is explicitly written from your point of view, you aren't contesting the bias.
The reason the bias is an important thing to qualify the rest of the article is because bias gets in the way of our ability to pursue informational accuracy and relevance, and to avoid using an encyclopedia to argue for specific ideologies or ways of analyzing an event. I'm not surprised a ban was threatened; it seems a consistent pattern with your edits that they *do* platform your ideological arguments and analyses without adequate telegraphing or relevance to the articles they are on, and that's just not what this wiki is for Oceanstar (talk) 01:32, 5 September 2026 (UTC)Reply

Un true

Rain is mentioned as an honourary citizen of danzilona which is not the case. Rain is an honourary resident / normal resident. Goneguy (talk) 14:07, 2 October 2026 (UTC)Reply