Worm Island Dispute

From CivWiki
Jump to navigation Jump to search
Worm Island Dispute

Worm Island
Location
Belligerents

Second Kingdom of Soderrike

Soderrike Shadow Council
Wormseed

For more information, see Soderrike Shadow Council and Soderrike.

The Worm Island Dispute was between Wormseed and the Imperial Federation state the Second Kingdom of Soderrike / the Soderrike Shadow Council that secretly governed the state, over whether their island would remain part of Soderrike, or be ceded to the neighbouring state of Kraftsborg, to allow Wormseed to switch communities while remaining living in Worm Hall, their house on the island.

Context

Wormseed and Soderrike's ruling clique were in a long-term antagonistic relationship prior to the dispute.

Wormseed and SoftKitten5 had governed Soderrike between January and June 2025 under the Republic of Soderrike; however, in late June, Soft betrayed Wormseed, joining forces with Xsyrok (an alt of Artray) to remove Wormseed as leader and replace the Republic with the Soderrikish Union government.

In early July, Soft performed a self-coup as the Union's General Secretary; Xsy and Wormseed joined forces in a pro-democracy counter-coup called the Soderrike Army Faction. However, after securing power Xsy betrayed the SAF, joining forces with Soft to establish the Second Kingdom of Soderrike.

Wormseed's house, Worm Hall on the remote Worm Island, is CivMC's southernmost dwelling and Wormseed's first build on the server. It had previously hosted the struggle between Wormseed, Xsy and Soft during the Battle of Worm Island, during the Fall of the Republic of Soderrike, in which Wormseed and Leadattic had fought Soft and Xsy on the ice adjacent to the island.

July 8th (Origins of the Dispute)

On July 8th, SoftKitten5 replied to Wormseed's refusal to pledge allegiance (see above); "No one gives a fuck... Also your island is gonna stay Söderrikish".[1] At 6:57, Xsy suggested to Wormseed that Worm Island be ceded to Kraftsborg, after Wormseed threatened to pearl-on-site anyone who broke into Worm Hall; "i dont think anyone wants to break into your house... move to kraftsborg... we can make your house island part of kraftsborg... How does that sound".[2] Wormseed reluctantly consented; "I'd rather that than have it still be part of soderrike I guess".[3] At 8:56, they and Frosted Cupcakes confirmed that Kraftsborg consented to this potential deal.[4]

July 9th (Anti-Wormseed Plot)

On July 9th, the Soderrike Shadow Council discussed assassinating Wormseed; at 11:15 PM, RealityTheory brought up Wormseed's proposed transfer of Worm Island from Soderrike to Kraftsborg, and Soft described them as "a danger that must be properly dealt with".[5] RealityTheory suggested "Pearl-On-Sight? lol", and argued "could pay someone to do it" when SoftKitten pointed out "We can’t legally do that".

Xsy expressed a similar desire to assassinate Wormseed, but also pointed out that this would be illegal under IF law.[6] RealityTheory responded by suggesting assassinating Wormseed under an alt-account, and "contacting interested and volatile third party via discord".[7] Xsy ended the possibility of assassination; "we can just isolate him... we dont need to kill him".[8]

At 11:21 PM, SoftKitten suggested levying a 100% tax on mined resources within Soderrike so as to have a legal pretext to arrest Wormseed for infringement, "Because I have seen him gathering resources inside soderrike".[9] He clarified that this proposed tax would only apply to foreigners (Wormseed's citizenship had just been revoked); he also explained that they would execute the plan by using snitches or radar mod to stalk Wormseed as soon as she logged on, "and if we catch him mining we can just charge him with breaking local law".[10] To enable this, Xsy planned to invest 400 diamonds into establishing a surveillance network of logsnitches across the country, which the Shadow Council would vein-mine over the next few days to cover the costs of.[11]

At 11:24 PM, RealityTheory suggested staging a false-flag terrorist attack on Soderrike, so as to frame Wormseed; "We could make land mines... Bomb a building we don’t like... And blame them on him".[12]

At 11:26 PM, SoftKitten asked RealityTheory to "edit the wiki... It’s heavily biased and it’s just him throwing shit at us".[13][14]

Xsy removed Wormseed from Soderrike's namelayers at Soft's instruction.[15]

July 10th

On July 10th at 8:49pm, SoftKitten5 opened a renaming competition for the island Wormseed's house was built on;[16] suggested names included the following:

Time Name Creator Reason Verdict
9:04pm Wormburg Reality_Theory This one becomes the new wormburg
11:09pm Little Icenia SoftKitten5
12:24am Wurmeiland SoftKitten5 1) it’s in söderrikish

2) fits and follows the inhabitants request

2:50am Banana Island Banana_Blu Rejected by Soft; "that one already exists"
2:57am Schlong Island Reality_Theory Like Long Island but Swedish
2:58am Seed Island Xsy
2:58am Isle of Wurm Reality_Theory
2:59am Isle of Beer and Gambling Xsy "thats what im calling it actually... executive order" -Xsy

Shortly thereafter, Xsy renamed it Beer and Gambling Island by executive order.[17]

At 11:30pm, Wormseed claimed that in voice-chat with IF negotiator HassDaMan during the Fall of the Republic of Soderrike, "Xsy guaranteed that the island would remain mine in vc with HassDaMan, to persuade me to return to the country... the island is mine."[18]

At 11:33pm in the Shadow Council, RealityTheory suggested a more conciliatory option; "could counter offer that the house itself can be a kraftsborg embassy but nothing outside of the walls is anything but soderrike".[19] However, Soft disagreed, claiming he had "suggested it to be a condominium;"[19] Xsy and RealityTheory soon agreed not to cede the island, as "we can’t change the borders every time someone gets mad that’s crazy talk... Are we giving kaiserburg back to Kaiser if he gets unbanned lmao... Did we let Samy make a country".[19]

July 11th

At 12:41am, Xsy announced "Eastern Island will stay part of Soderrike for as long as Soderrike is on the map... If any idiots attempt border violence or skirmishes I will personally respond to the threat". SoftKitten5 concurred; "I will not negotiate with republicans or traitors, the eastern island belong to SÖDERRIKE," and posted the coat of arms of the Second Kingdom, and of the Royal Authority (see Soderrike).[20]

At 12:27 PM in the Shadow Council, Xsy told Soft to "contact the admins... tell them he (Wormseed) is full of shit". However, Volution (who had just been contacted by Wormseed) reached out to Xsy and told him "not to engage".[21]

Meanwhile, Xsy polled citizens on whether Wormseed should be "given an island"; "No" won by 7 out of 11 votes (SoftKitten5, Banana, Johnny, Chadtodd55561, Xsyrok, RealityTheory and itsr4ally[22]), with 4 against (Jetsky, William, Ambystorm and Demobottle[23]).[24] Wormseed was not given an opportunity to vote, as their citizenship had been revoked. However, it is doubtful whether the referendum would have changed the Shadow Council's decision even if it had supported Wormseed, as they were already drafting "an statement saying that the island isn’t his property" in preparation for any ticket opened by Wormseed on the subject, reminding one another to include "a reason to keep it... besides "i want it"".[25]

Soft's prepared statement read as follows: "“The island isn’t wormseed’s property, it was a proposal but nothing really official, he can have his home and be entitled to his property rights but the majority of my citizens have agreed that there’s no reason to give it up*".[26]

At 12:36 AM, Xsy announced a plan to "we'll let it (the Worm Island Dispute) escalate and then remove him (Wormseed) from the IF".[27]

Debate

Later July 11th, Wormseed published a Suggestion entitled 'Can we just end this already and then I'll be out of your hair', asking for "my tiny island between the east coast of Soderrike and Kraftsborg to be transferred to Kraftsborg", because "the island has nothing on it except my house, and serves no benefit to Soderrike whatsoever... I don't like being around you two, I want out, so let me leave with my house that I'm so proud of... I just want this drama to end."

She explained her reasons for wanting to leave; "Soft is making the community hostile for me to be in, with constand timeouts, the removal of citizenship etc. I have blocked him, and I have got citizenship in Kraftsborg. But I think it would be unfair to force me to leave this house behind in Soderrike, for them to either abandon, demolish or steal from me, when the border I want it to extend into is right next to it. The decision to try and force me to give up the island if I want to leave serves (in my opinion) no purpose except to try and make me upset, out of petty spite."[28]

BananaBlu joined the discussion to argue that the island was valuable to Soderrike; "i mean to be fair the island is basically as big as the average soderrikish town and your house takes up a small part of it".[29] Demobottle argued for "some co ownership... and make a treaty and cool statue to establish and reafirm our close ties... also wormseed as a designer."[30][31]

SoftKitten5 argued "you have property rights... And the vast majority of citizens support the island staying inside söderrike" (citing the above poll). Wormseed argued that these citizens should not be able to influence this matter, because none of them lived on the island, to which Soft responded "We believe in democracy... And popular sovereignty".

Wormseed's response was that even if this were true, it was irrelevant to their argument for why they should be allowed the island; "Soft for once can we just skip the theatrics? I don't want to be around you, but I want to live in my house. This won't hurt anyone and you don't want to be around me either, I bet. Please, it's in both of our interests". Frosted Cupcakes made a legal argument that as Wormseed was the sole resident of the island, asking them would be "in the name of popular sovereignty".[32] However, he concluded "you don’t care about the island soft, you just want to annoy worm".[33]

At 12:40 PM, the Soderrikish government officially opposed the transfer; Xsy announced "Eastern Island will stay part of Soderrike for as long as Soderrike is on the map... If any idiots attempt border violence or skirmishes I will personally respond to the threat," and SoftKitten5 announced "I will not negotiate with republicans or traitors, the eastern island belong to SÖDERRIKE".

References