Talk:Invasion of the Sea Peoples/Archive1 Reception
Oceanstar claims in their edit that audience reception of the events are irrelevant if their reception is not acknowledged by the participants of the event. This is... a very interesting claim. There are many examples of wiki pages that feature reception, feedback, or criticism sections/mentions where no proof is provided of the participants acknowledging the public's reception. Refer[1][2]
Oceanstar also simplified a pledge of support down to a "personal opinion" in order to make her case seem more compelling. Oceanstar also insists the Civ+ nation of Leviticus should have posted about their supoort within CivMC channels, electing to ignore the leaders unspecified ban from CivMC. Showing support across servers in times of conflict is not unheard of, this situation is no different. RainOfPain125 (talk) 01:05, 25 August 2026 (UTC)
- *her.
- Firstly, I do not think the cases you have cited are at all equivalent to the scenario in question here. Those are works of art, engaging with Civ as a genre and inviting cultural response; while the article in discussion here is of geopolitical subject, and so the things listed here should have some kind of geopolitical relevance- the public reception of a faction during a war is very relevant, but "public" here refers to CivMC's population, which is effected by the war. And yes, it's absolutely true that the statements made by the direct parties of a conflict have more relevance to it than outside observers; they inform analysis of their intentions and motivations, and are informative to the reader of the article, which is the main function of this wiki.
- Secondly, if Leviticus's pledge of support was representative of a larger interest group than that of its leader, who made the edit to the wiki page, presumably someone in that nation would've been able to express that support in a forum that CivMC's playerbase could've engaged with. As it stands, that pledge, being a unilateral judgement by a single individual expressed most readily to the audience of this article *by the article itself*- which should be considered a descriptive tool rather than a platform- can be safely described as a personal opinion. And, to be clear, my judgement wasn't that Leviticus's proclamation *should* have been made in a CivMC-centric forum for its own sake- I don't suppose any party interested in proper information is looking for advice on how to artificially generate relevance to a wiki article; and I don't think anyone here is interested in litigating the circumstances of individual bans on this article specifically- but simply that, as it was not, it is not relevant here.
- At the very least, I think Leviticus's stance on this conflict needs to be reported in the context of how this war effects other Civ servers at-large, when and if it does so- for example, if it has demographic or political effects, like how wars on previous iterations have sparked migrations and raids genre-wide. Civwiki does also have a place for archiving things relevant to the genre overall, *including* personal opinions, but I think those should be left to specific pages with subjects appropriate for their scope, and I'm just not convinced that a single statement from a nation leader on another iteration about an ongoing war is helpful to the people who will be looking for this article now, and could be potentially misleading to readers in the future without the context we have here. Oceanstar (talk) 02:08, 25 August 2026 (UTC)
- agree with oceanstar Tybug (talk) 03:04, 25 August 2026 (UTC)
- +1 as well, the opinion currently just dilutes the article as this conflict does not seemingly affect other servers so far Specificlanguage (talk) 03:38, 25 August 2026 (UTC)
- "their" is grammatically correct regardless if the person they are describing is he/she/they. RedBeanPastry (talk) 03:24, 25 August 2026 (UTC)
- Only ever using they/them when you are aware of someone's pronouns being the contrary is consitered by some to be a form of misgendering. Still, I don't think this was Rain's aim. I think he just didn't know Oceanstar's pronouns. Amelorate (talk) 03:32, 25 August 2026 (UTC)
- they/them wouldn't be misgendering me in any case, I use they/them pretty regularly. the relevant issue here was the "his" in the second paragraph, and yeah I don't think it was intentional and I'm not bothered by it, just wanted to clarify Oceanstar (talk) 03:34, 25 August 2026 (UTC)
- I was only using "their" to refer to the hypothetical audience. She is correct that I miswrote "his claim" instead of writing neutrally "their claim" but now I know it is "her claim" so it has been fixed accordingly. RainOfPain125 (talk) 04:14, 25 August 2026 (UTC)
- Only ever using they/them when you are aware of someone's pronouns being the contrary is consitered by some to be a form of misgendering. Still, I don't think this was Rain's aim. I think he just didn't know Oceanstar's pronouns. Amelorate (talk) 03:32, 25 August 2026 (UTC)
and so the things listed here should have some kind of geopolitical relevance- CivMC has been running for... 4 years now? 4 years of dropchested pvp gear sitting around waiting to be used at any moment. To be used by anyone on the server, on their 1st day or 1000th. That seems a little relevant. Everyone opposed to world police is on principle a friend of Leviticus, regardless of server, and we later elaborated that publicly.[3][4]
Secondly, if Leviticus's pledge of support was representative of a larger interest group than that of its leader, who made the edit to the wiki page, presumably someone in that nation would've been able to express that support in a forum that CivMC's playerbase could've engaged with.- This seems like genetic fallacy. I am a prolific civwiki editor in a sea of players who couldn't give a care for creating an account and writing pages. Just because I am the one adding to the record does not mean I am 'only representing myself' as you seem to be suggesting. Leviticus is currently the largest group on Civ+ with a discord of 200+ members. Merely because I advise them against participating in CivMC channels of communication due to repeat documented abuses of power from the CivMC admins, does not indicate a lack of representation.
At the very least, I think Leviticus's stance on this conflict needs to be reported in the context of how this war effects other Civ servers at-large, when and if it does so- for example, if it has demographic or political effects, like how wars on previous iterations have sparked migrations and raids genre-wide.I'm just not convinced that a single statement from a nation leader on another iteration about an ongoing war is helpful- This is an on-going conflict. I don't think you can fault us if we cannot yet know or predict how this invasion and the Levitican support/pledge/comms with the Sea People effects CivMC or "Civ servers at-large". Including the reception and pledge seems important in the context of expanding the audience's idea of how this conflict may have the potential to result in cross-server activities, even if it has not yet occured. RainOfPain125 (talk) 05:17, 25 August 2026 (UTC)
- >CivMC has been running for... 4 years now? 4 years of dropchested pvp gear sitting around waiting to be used at any moment. To be used by anyone on the server, on their 1st day or 1000th. That seems a little relevant. Everyone opposed to world police is on principle a friend of Leviticus, regardless of server, and we later elaborated that publicly.
- I don't think the nebulous threat of hypothetical gear dropchested at the SOTW by players now on other iterations to be distributed if some threshold of interest is met by people who have been thus far uninvolved constitutes a relevant factor for the purposes of the wiki.
- >This seems like genetic fallacy. I am a prolific civwiki editor in a sea of players who couldn't give a care for creating an account and writing pages. Just because I am the one adding to the record does not mean I am 'only representing myself' as you seem to be suggesting. Leviticus is currently the largest group on Civ+ with a discord of 200+ members. Merely because I advise them against participating in CivMC channels of communication due to repeat documented abuses of power from the CivMC admins, does not indicate a lack of representation.
- I'm going to put aside the matter of Leviticus's population, relevance, and whether the national consciousness can be sufficiently embodied in a single author, because it's not meaningfully quantifiable or even really arguable without contrasting sources. The fact that Leviticus has chosen so far to remain completely uninvolved in the affairs of CivMC is actually central to my entire point- they are fundamentally, and unarguably, unrepresented in CivMC's population, history, and current politics, which are the current scope of the article.
- >This is an on-going conflict. I don't think you can fault us if we cannot yet know or predict how this invasion and the Levitican support/pledge/comms with the Sea People effects CivMC or "Civ servers at-large". Including the reception and pledge seems important in the context of expanding the audience's idea of how this conflict may have the potential to result in cross-server activities, even if it has not yet occured.
- I am not faulting anyone, but I don't think the wiki's job is to encourage or engage in speculative fantasy. If these subjects were a topic of general discussion within CivMC's public, or within the broader genre as a whole- ideally from several unrelated sources, to be as comprehensive as possible- it might be worth including, but that is just obviously not the case right now.
- I apologize if this comes across impolitely, but I feel your responsibility as a nation leader towards platforming the interests, opinions, and history of your country is competing with your responsibility as a wiki editor towards the pursuit of information and clarity. Leviticus deserves a place on Civwiki to discuss and preserve those things, but Leviticus, as an outside party to CivMC, cannot alone decide its own relevance to this article. Oceanstar (talk) 06:49, 25 August 2026 (UTC)
- agree with oceanstar Tybug (talk) 03:04, 25 August 2026 (UTC)