Talk:List of conflicts on CivMC
Latest comment: 27 June 2025 by SocialistRuler1 in topic What is the definition of a conflict?
What is the definition of a conflict?
Wars are conflicts, not all conflicts are wars. A military operation waged against a nation is a conflict, but not all conflicts fall under either of these definitions. SocialistRuler1 (talk) 21:28, 26 June 2025 (UTC)
- For the sake of Civ I would say that conflict is when one group clicks on another group or another group's infra. The obvious question here is do Volterra's recent pearlings count as that? But considering how the pearlings are generally separate and are only really associated with one another by the density of their occurrences (and some select shared circumstances), I'm hesitant to call it a single conflict of its own.
- That's why I reverted that addition, I just don't see it as a single conflict between two organized groups, at worst it's Volterra deciding to pearl a bunch of non-ASNers (not specifically IF either) for lulz and at best it's a bunch of pearlings whose justifications do exist but haven't really been publicized very well. If it becomes apparent that it's the former- a sustained campaign designed solely to pearl non-ASNers- then it probably should be added back, but for now I feel it should be treated as a brief, unfortunate trend that emerged Presidentofyes12 (talk) 22:02, 26 June 2025 (UTC)
- These are good points, and I understand why you removed it from the main conflicts page for now. While I still believe these incidents could potentially qualify as a 'conflict', because despite lacking the scale or explicit coordination/unifying goal of a traditional conflict, the pattern of actions suggests a potential targeted campaign rather than isolated incidents. But I agree that without further public evidence, it’s premature to include it on this wiki page. Your definition of 'conflict' for CivMC’s context makes sense, and I appreciate you creating a separate page to document these events. SocialistRuler1 (talk) 02:19, 27 June 2025 (UTC)