Talk:List of Civ Servers

From CivWiki
Latest comment: 24 October by Specificlanguage in topic Civ server list consolidation
Jump to navigation Jump to search

Civ server list consolidation

There's several attempts for lists of Civ servers (Category:Servers, this page, List of Civ Servers ordered by page edits, Draft:List of Civ Servers) and I do want to basically consolidate all of these pages into one canonical page, because this is getting annoying. The problem is that I think every page we make is very user unfriendly, and I sort of want to consolidate them into a page that feels (1) very easy to navigate for someone who wants to find a new (or old) Civ server (2) gets basic information across (e.g. like the timeline) and (3) is comprehensive

This has been something I have been wanting to do for a while, but kicking off this discussion so I don't step on anyone's toes. I am opening this discussion just to see what people consider the "best" parts of these lists and plan out a formal replacement that anyone can link to.

Insert meme about xkcd standards here Specificlanguage (talk) 17:54, 24 October 2026 (UTC)Reply

List of Civ Servers ordered by page edits should probably just be deleted. It's been outdated for three years, and predates most of the current active civ servers.
Someone mentioned it in a discord discussion but I agree with what they said: It's weird for Category:Servers to have its content be more than just a short blurb about what should and shouldn't be in the list.
Scrolling through wikipedia, a list typically is organized like so (basing off of w:List of James Bond films:
=List of Things=
  • Blurb about what a Thing is
  • Table of Things, detailing everything that's relevant
  • A number of sections about each individual notible Thing, with {{Main|Thingy Thing}} links when relevant articles exist
Based on that, List of Civ Servers is probably the closest page to those criteria.
List of Civ Servers also has the best SEO of any of our many lists of the kind.
Amelorate (talk) 18:02, 24 October 2026 (UTC)Reply
In terms of semantics purposes yes I think this argument makes sense. That's fair that this would be the correct page, however I also personally think this table feels very bloated for what it is, and makes it a little hard for someone to find a server they're looking for. My usecase, I imagine, is that this would be the ideal link for "More servers" from the front page. However, my issues with this current page is being relatively user-unfriendly on finding a Civ server. This is why I'm trying to take inspiration from how other pages have been constructed to better inspire this one.
Some thoughts of mine:
  • "Differences between online servers" feels like the wrong header to use
  • Even though this page has the best SEO, this table definitely needs some info reform as I still find it very hard to navigate. I don't think folks are necessarily looking on this page for server size, website, start date, version, or for past servers their IP, discord, etc.
  • I also think the default order is definitely off. Respectfully, though Civ+ is first, on average it may not be the first one I'm trying to look for, even though it is manually sorted by days by default (I would argue this number feels off, but that's a can of worms for another discussion).
Some aspects of the others I like (admittedly, I am biased too):
  • More "active" servers and historically significant servers are first, a little quicker to find a server of a certain era and such
  • These are more to the point although admittedly not enough information is there
Specificlanguage (talk) 18:48, 24 October 2026 (UTC)Reply