Talk:Grasslands Gambit: Difference between revisions
Jump to navigation
Jump to search
Content added Content deleted
No edit summary |
(forgot signature) |
||
| Line 25: | Line 25: | ||
'''Disagree''': While I do agree the name must be changed, the name War of the '''Dawn Guard''' is misleading, since while Gang Shi did definitely provide a casual belli, it did not initiate the war or launch the first attack. It can also make the war seem 'Black and White', which I personally dislike. [[User:Walpole|Walpole]] ([[User talk:Walpole|talk]]) 14:30, 17 December 2023 (UTC) |
'''Disagree''': While I do agree the name must be changed, the name War of the '''Dawn Guard''' is misleading, since while Gang Shi did definitely provide a casual belli, it did not initiate the war or launch the first attack. It can also make the war seem 'Black and White', which I personally dislike. [[User:Walpole|Walpole]] ([[User talk:Walpole|talk]]) 14:30, 17 December 2023 (UTC) |
||
: I don't really see how these points disprove the name, to be fair. Dawn Guard is one of the most used terminology nowadays to refer to the Icenia/Yoahtl alliance during the war; it's been pretty good at marking whether this war is the current one or a previous Icenia/Yoahtl-affair like the [[Butternut-SEC War]]. There's already pretty well-known several instances of wars in real-life having pretty biased names towards one side (e.g. French and Indian). If you've got an alternative name that could be agreeable, I'd be happy to hear it though. |
: I don't really see how these points disprove the name, to be fair. Dawn Guard is one of the most used terminology nowadays to refer to the Icenia/Yoahtl alliance during the war; it's been pretty good at marking whether this war is the current one or a previous Icenia/Yoahtl-affair like the [[Butternut-SEC War]]. There's already pretty well-known several instances of wars in real-life having pretty biased names towards one side (e.g. French and Indian). If you've got an alternative name that could be agreeable, I'd be happy to hear it though. [[User:Specificlanguage|Specificlanguage]] ([[User talk:Specificlanguage|talk]]) 20:58, 17 December 2023 (UTC) |
||